2016: Started all 19 games for the Red Foxes...Had a career high 2 goals, scoring vs Vermont 9/17 and at Siena 11/2...Had a career high with 2 assist with 1 each at St. Bonaventure 9/26 and at Saint Peter's 10/22...Had a season high three shots vs Vermont 9/17...Had a season high 2 shots on goal and scored the game winner at Siena 11/2...Finished with a career high 19 shots and 8 shots on goal.
2015: MAAC All-Academic Team... Played in 15 games, starting eight. Scored his first career goal, the game winner, in a 2-0 win at Rider on Sept. 26th. Finished the season with seven shots total and four shots on goal.
2014: MAAC All-Academic Team... Appeared in seven games for the Red Foxes, starting two... Finished with one assist on the season.
2013: MAAC All-Academic Team... Appeared in four games, starting one... Attempted two shots.
2012: Did not appear in any games.
Prior to Marist: Flatley was named a Top Drawer Soccer Player to Watch in 2011. While playing interscholastically at Seton Hall Prep, he helped his squad to a no. 1 ranking amongst U.S. High School programs in 2010 and capped his career with a 37-3-3 record over his junior and senior seasons. He was named to All-County and All-Conference teams in 2011. While with Ironbound SC, Flatley was a part of two USL Super Y-League North American Championship teams as well as a US Club Soccer National Cup Champion.